Constructive Dismissal – Labour Law Attorneys in Johannesburg
Managing Constructive Dismissal Risks
Jansen van Vuuren Schnehage Attorneys Inc. advises and represents employers in constructive dismissal disputes, with a particular focus on managing risk and ensuring that workplace conduct remains legally defensible.
Constructive dismissal arises where an employee alleges that the employer has rendered continued employment intolerable, effectively leaving the employee with no reasonable alternative but to resign. These claims are inherently complex. They require not only a careful analysis of the factual matrix but also a proper application of established legal principles, including the burden of proof resting on the employee and the objective assessment of intolerability.
Employers are often exposed to such claims in circumstances where internal processes, communication breakdowns or management decisions are challenged, after the fact. For this reason, early legal intervention is critical in both defending claims and preventing them from arising.
Scope of Services
Our involvement typically begins with a detailed assessment of the allegations giving rise to the constructive dismissal claim. This includes an evaluation of the surrounding workplace dynamics, the conduct of both employer and employee and the extent to which internal remedies were available or exhausted.
We provide strategic advice aimed at mitigating risk, both in response to an existing dispute and in preventing escalation within the workplace. Where matters proceed formally, we represent employers in proceedings before the CCMA and relevant Bargaining Councils, ensuring that the employer’s position is clearly articulated and properly supported by evidence.
Our services extend to the full defence of arbitration proceedings, including the preparation and presentation of evidence, witness management and the development of a structured legal argument.
Our Services
From an advisory perspective, we conduct a thorough evaluation of workplace practices and decisions that may give rise to allegations of intolerability. This often involves identifying areas of potential vulnerability and advising on corrective measures to stabilise the employment relationship, where possible. Preventative legal guidance forms a key part of this process, particularly in high-risk or sensitive workplace environments.
In the context of representation, we defend employers in constructive dismissal disputes by carefully interrogating both the factual and legal basis of the employee’s claim. Particular emphasis is placed on demonstrating that the working environment was not objectively intolerable and that reasonable alternatives to resignation existed.
Where appropriate, we engage in structured settlement discussions aimed at resolving disputes efficiently and cost-effectively. In cases where arbitration awards are adverse, we advise on the prospects of success in Labour Court review proceedings and, where justified, proceed accordingly.
Legal Framework
Constructive dismissal claims are governed primarily by the Labour Relations Act, which defines dismissal to include circumstances where an employee terminates the employment relationship due to the employer’s conduct.
The development of this area of law has been significantly shaped by case law, which establishes that the employee bears the onus of proving that continued employment was objectively intolerable and that resignation was a last resort. These principles are central to the defence of such claims and inform the strategic approach adopted in each matter.
Why Legal Guidance is Critical
Constructive dismissal disputes present a particular risk to employers due to their often subjective nature. Without proper legal guidance, employers may struggle to effectively counter allegations that are framed around perceptions of unfairness or hostility in the workplace.
Adverse findings may result in compensation awards, as well as judicial commentary on the employer’s conduct, which can have broader implications for internal governance and employee relations. In addition, these disputes frequently expose underlying organisational issues that, if left unaddressed, may give rise to further claims.
Our Approach
Our approach is grounded in early identification and management of risk. We work closely with employers to assess situations as they arise, providing clear and practical guidance aimed at preventing escalation wherever possible.
Where disputes cannot be avoided, we adopt a structured and strategic defence, focusing on the evidentiary and legal requirements necessary to rebut a claim of constructive dismissal.
At the same time, we remain mindful of the broader workplace context and, where appropriate, propose practical solutions to restore stability and reduce the likelihood of future disputes.
Who We Assist
We act for employers, management teams, and HR professionals who are required to navigate complex workplace disputes and who seek legally sound and commercially practical solutions.
Contact Our Labour Law Attorneys
Constructive dismissal claims require careful handling from the outset. Early engagement with experienced legal advisors can significantly influence both the outcome of the dispute and the management of broader workplace risk.
For assistance with constructive dismissal matters, contact Jansen van Vuuren Schnehage Attorneys Inc.
Why Choose Jansen van Vuuren Schnehage Attorneys Inc?
- Johannesburg-based specialist attorneys with in-depth knowledge of South African law
- A multi-disciplinary legal team offering comprehensive legal services
- Practical, solution-driven advice with a strong commercial focus
- High ethical standards, professionalism, and client confidentiality
- Personalised service and direct access to experienced attorneys
Quick links
Copyright 2026 | JVVS Attorneys | All Rights Reserved